Yearly All-time list update...
My yearly all-time list update, plus newer additions to Curator reviews...
First thing’s first… Latest steam curations. Also, BIAS on top of BIAS alert: The Succubus Stories developer is my only paid sub on Substack. I try to make sure these things are documented for full transparency. I did earnestly enjoy Succubus Stories, it’s how I grew to get to know Artisan… But I feel its honest to say…
Also take a moment to do the thing… Creators are under seige:
Good Reddit thread on what you can do...
Now, for the main event… I kinda just ripped this from where it began and slightly edited it… So some references or things said may be weird?
(Updated 8-7-2025)
Here's my favorites of all-time on a tier list.
(Note: This will be evolved if I find new ones I enjoy alot)
My criteria: Depth of gameplay, art quality, quality writing, fetish fulfillment and completion. My favorite fetishes are: Pregnancy (Strongly prefer non-game ending), Corruption, Harem, Monster Girls, Yuri/Lesbian, Futanari, Trainer/Management and Character Creation. Least favorite: Ryona/Excessive violence, "First Person NTR" (The game makes YOU feel NTR'd) and Scat/Piss (Scat and Piss arent deal breakers though). Bad MTL can make me laugh, so I dont take points off for that. There is a chance I have missed one you may really like, for example I have not tried the much beloved "Being a DIK" game, I just dont feel it along with WMU, even though they have some elements I approve of. If you feel I have missed one I may really enjoy, let me know.
THE GOATs (My all-time greats with actual comments):
Harem Hotel
What would a list from me be without this game and I will mention it first, simply a masterwork of what a porn game could be and with pregnancy a promised addition, I look forward to the day I make Ashley preggers. It is heavily reliant on it's Honey Select 2 groundwork, but despite this, it is THE perfect game. Maria and The Android were once mid-level and forgettable characters, then were re-written and are now top-tier characters themselves. Boring semi-open world? Runey adds roming and you can find fun tidbits in game. You can even say you forget that it is pretty running on borrowed HS2 assets, but with a colorful and vibrant cast with an endless selection of best girls and stellar writing from Runey, it's the best Harem game that gives you everything you want from genre and then he will go out and fix the kinks in the armor. BEST WRITING.
Trials in Tainted Space
Let me just say this, yeah, its not perfect but it checks alot of boxes. It really needs to work on finishing Steele's tale before adding another side scene off the beaten path that takes you travelling to a side area that isnt along the main path to do that requires you jumping through hoops, or waiting X days to do. Best FLASH game. On HTML, not so much.
Lilith's Throne
See TiTS x 10. Enough orange ballsacks. Finish the main story. Stop stalling. There is more than enough fetish content for Patrons and more isnt needed, they can cope. That content, is what puts it here on my list. This and TiTS do transformations, pregnancy and character creation PERFECTLY and thats why they are here. There is alot of self-management here too. Good side quests, along with TiTS make this a fun game BUT both skeletons need more muscle and fat. TiTS has finally been working towards completion more and its time Innoxia cuts the crap and joins the frey. Really has an epic ending building and could surpass HH if it ends as I hope with a Mass Effect 3 style choice option end, but without sucking. Best on JAVA.
Ravager
When I started this, I wouldnt have imagined placing this here but it belongs. It's a game with a cornucopia of great things happening. First of all, I know I am a big fucking dragon as a protag and it... doesnt matter. Yeah. I mean that. Second, your BFD is given a wonderful harem of completely off their rocker characters devoted to you for being you (Darja) and pleasant surprises that you NEVER expected to happen the way they did (Heloise the Inquisitrix) and many more from a hilarious drunk to a femboy gobbo to neko twins and things in between. You are given freedom to do as you please. Be a savage beast or prove you are above it all and overcome your bestial nature OR do things in-between. NPCs even come alive in this game and feel worthy to get to know. Also, you get armies to do as you please with. On Renpy. Yeah. All done on Renpy. With Handdrawn art. What a game, what an experience this is and now you can play the first 4 chapters for free.
Good Girl Gone Bad
Wonderful hand-drawn self-corruption game featuring numerous pathways and incredibly fun and interesting side characters. My only ending was as a sex-positive model as I missed out on the star of the show, Jasmin (a well-written black herm girl). Best ARTWORK, but not by much. Best completed game I have played so far. Jasmin was "extra content" no less and I liked her the most.
Tomie wants to get married
Take a girl living in a dystopian society that treats women--- poorly--- and have her try to move about life from day to day. Your personal choices can lead to some bad to horrible things happening, not to the level of LonaRPG, but some pretty bad shit. Women are pretty commodities to exploit in this game and Tomie doesnt really ever question this. You do your best to get her what she wants. To be married to a nice guy that treats her right and brings her happiness, but nothing is all that it seems. Also, pretty innovative mechanics to advance days. Corruption gameplay is damn good here. Pregnancy bad end without being able to find a guy with a kid or find an outcome with a kid, takes it down a peg. Still, happy to have help Ollane through most of development/the pandemic. Money well spent imho.
Vae Victis: Conquer, Ravish, Breed.
An excellent kingdom management sim that morphs into harem management as well as you add rulers of your conquered lands to your side as your harem. Big ups for having a sexy non-stereotypical black female harem option. Total death by snu snu she is--- and what I saw is from an older build. Doorknob has since added MORE, including Gobbo waifus. It just keeps getting better.
Inner Growth
Great and very sexy FUTA demon girl protag who comes with a pre-given pregnant BY YOU sexy dark elf waifu then you get a sexy tattooed girl pimp waifu and succubus waifus as well. HELL YES! Wild plot that feels set up to give a wildly fun protag moar top tier waifus than anything else as it should be. Still has more to add and update (if it completes, it stays!) and if the ending doesnt involve you dethroning, dominating and subsequently breeding your mother to pregnancy who you NTR'd, the Demon Queen, I'll be GREATLY disappointed.
Life with a Slave: Teaching Feeling
When I started this, I didnt know what to expect. What I got was a precious girl that needs love, healing, attention and pretty dresses. "My Dress-up Sex Darling" with burns and a dark and sordid history. An experience that must be done for anyone who likes management/trainers. Best TRANSLATION.
President Yukino
My favorite NTR game. You start as the book smart/street stupid Yukino and you can either keep her pure by any means necessary or just throw caution to the wind and turn her into the degenerate she was meant to be. Only flaw: No pregnancy. Wolf RPG > RPGM.
Bad Memories
Favorite LGBT game as there is a 100% no dicks lesbian path. Very refreshing. The male path is fun as well, but the lesbian path is what sets it apart. Well written story by another excellent writer. Best LGBTQ game. Still updating too.
Love and Sex: Second Base
Fantastic sandbox dating sim game filled to the brim of lovely dating interests and some of the girls are obvious direct references to characters like Shiori being an obvious take on Kawakami of Persona 5 and your boss Aletta being a near twin in appearance and character to the Warden from Prison School and even more references to make your head spin. Plus an excellent Yandere (Kylie). Also, big respect for the Ayesha character as a whole from what I saw. Within it, he also gave one of the best descriptions of wrestling to a novice viewer I have ever read. There are too many reasons to gush about this so here goes my negatives: "Mike" the MC is a real wimp that can be a cringe inducing Nice Guy (TM) at times. Dev inserting his "anti-SJW" hottakes within the game sporadically including calling Aletta a "feminazi" in dialogue for example. To me, I see a Summertime Saga with a somewhat better looking chad thundercock MC and better gameplay with amazing artwork. Potential no dick Lesbian playthrough as Bree possible but still being completed, which make this a BETTER Saga overall than Dark Cookie's mea culpa.
Projekt Passion
Going to keep this short and sweet, it's my own Projekt Moon Hope Awakens with a male protag and far better looking graphics.
Hilarious AVN. Worth your time, effort and energy.
Baldur's Gate 3:
Best Mature rated game that contains sexual content. The Minthara scene in Act 1 is as spicy as any game in here.
You don't really need another run down of BG3, do you?
Course of Temptation:
Now my best HTML game... motivated me to make In the Bag.
Grandma's House:
Bias showing here, but I love the humor and there are zero terrible girls and a cute doggo.
Morningstar: Book of the Fallen:
Amazing visuals, great hard rock soundtrack and interesting sequel to the Love of Magic series (I didn't play that), but as a stand alone, it's amazing and worth giving a chance. One of the most complete games I have played.
Me as a Steam curator:
(Note: In my Steam Curator list are "PC Councilors", which means games I was given that are top notch 9.5+ of 10 games.)
Damn good games, but not the best of the best. Maybe you like them more or less for varying reasons (Few comments, too many to list):
Accidental Woman, My Tuition Academia, Witch Trainer (w/Silver Mod), Friendship with Benefits (EXCELLENT!), Hentai University, The Depravity of a Lewd Vampire, Wife Trainer Files, Strive for Power, Jack of Nine Tails, Corruption, Girl Life (Best QSP), Renyru Ascension, Newlife, Porn Empire, Parental Love, Captured by Dark Elves: The Return of Arachna, Building our Futature, Her New Memory, Hole Dweller, Star Knightess Aura, Chemical Change, General Practioner, EratokoH, The Heiress, Sisterly Lust, Life with Mary, Monster Girl Club Bifrost (Best RPGM), The Vampire's Curse, Deviant Discoveries, Koikatsu Party, Honey Select 2, Hazumi and the Pregnation, Princess Party, Odyssey of Gianna, NewLife, Tyrant's Quest: Gold, SHELTER, Karryn's Prison (w/Preg Mod only), Seducing the Devil, Goblin Down, Companion of Darkness, Headpats and Handholding, Actual Roommates, Yuri University, Karryn's Prison (w/Pregnancy Mod), The Tyrant, Rogue-Like: Evolution, Monster Girl 1000, Vox Gremory, Monica's Newlywed Life, Magical Girl Konoha, Darkest Dungeon (with adult mods), Xtardew Valley (Stardew Valley NSFW Mod), MWNews, Enishia and the Binding Brand, Degrees of Lewdity, Instinct Unleashed, World Tamer, One Lie, Isabella: Crossing Shadows, A Home in the Desert, Nymphomania Priestess, Cyberlinxxx, Succubus Stories (pic below), Voidbound (see pic above),
Criminally underrated:
Academy LIVE! (pic below), Baskin: All in, Absolute Power Corruption (Most underrated), Portal Heart, Portal Heart 2, Falling Stars, Dragon of Calon Valley, Ruin Me, Crimson Veil, Lisa Total Investigation, Black Rose: A Netori Story (also pic below), Pookie has a Fantasy 1 and 2.
Fantastic BUT too unfinished/early OR abandoned OR slowly updated to be GOATs:
College Daze (updates are slow), Summertime Saga (Dont get it twisted, I love this. Eve rules.), Free Cities w/Mod (A great game as it is, but doomed franchise ig), Love and Corruption (needs more updates, but Airell gets it and this could be below LSSB soon!), , Dryad Quest RPG, Broken Dreams Correctional Center (TiTS but much much less travelling! Thank god!), Tales of LL: Aphrodisia, Book of Lust, Corruption of Champions 2, Lifeplay (Best Unreal Engine game), The Fixer, Salacious Sakura, Bonds of Blood, Hentai High School, Office Perks, Inn another World, Having a Hard Time,
Solid games, but may go up/down a tier with a replay or more time with it after recent updates:
Strive: Conquest, Quickie: A Love Hotel Story, My Demon Friend, Tales of Androgyny, Princess and Conquest, The Guide to being Assertive, The Secretary, The Inheritance, Corrupted Kingdoms, My Little Angel, Lust Doll Plus, Become Someone, Futadom World, Breeders of the Nephelem, Peasant's Quest, Slutcraft, Lunar's Chosen, The Assistant, Living in a Brothel, Lyndaria: Lust Adventure, The Making of a Slut, Lust Legion, Voidbound, Sunwave Hotel, Porn Empire,
Solid mostly SFW titles with NSFW elements:
Ace Academy, Faulty Apprentice, Best Elf (pic above), Loren the Amazon Princess, Akiba's Trip: Undead and Undressed, Pathfinder: WOTR, Atlyss,
My own game (Doesnt count but it exists):
Projekt Moon: Hope Awakens, In the Bag
Friend games/Mooniverse Dev games that I will play someday:
UNCF Icaros, Agents of Armor, Wartribe Academy, Nymphomania: Fantasy Town, Chronicles of Hell and Heaven, Sunville, Erisa's Summer, Secret Care Cafe, Funkelregen, Fates Crossed, Summer in the City, Naughty Lyanna, Lost in You, Mythos, Konosuba: The Harem Adventures, B.E.S.T., Power of Truth, Hex, BOOBIEs,
On my list and interested in:
Long Live the Princess, Alansya Chronicles: Fleeting Iris (played a little, reminds me of a slower Yukino so far), Astral Lust, W.S.I.G.H. from Recreation, Gone Home, Man of the House, The Shadow over Blackmore, Femdom City MANTIS, Rise of the White Flower, Fort of Chains, Vow me Fairies, Healslut (recieved alot of recommendations for this besides here), Whore Effect, Caliross: A Shapeshifter's Legacy, Shaggy's Power (lol), Tomboy Supremacy, Roundscape Androvia (should play more before I judge), Arevus, The Snow Daze games (all), Rebirth, IslanDeity, Shattered Lands, VIRTUES, Divimera, General Practitioner 2, Daughter of the Void, Love of Magic.
In Development hell:
The Company (a year and feels stagnant, what a shame), Lab Rats 2,
Most anticipated:
Fenoxo and Innoxia get their stuff together and FINISH. YOUR. GAMES.
My Demonic Romance, Peach Hills Division, Wings of Empire (Droid is space? Yes please!).
User recommended below, THANKS but not sure if I will try but appreciate the suggestion:
Divine Dawn, Tabletop Bornstar, Nexeus Institute, Blood Biter Beatdown, Infinity Realm
Not too bad, but not my cup of tea aka didnt like/wasnt into it for whatever reason:
Four Elements Trainer (lack of Avatar knowledge/VERY SLOW gameplay), BMO TV, Cloud Meadow (too much dungeon, not enough breeding), Whore of Babylon, Milfy City (rushed finish), Seeds of Chaos (too hardcore on the NTR, but GREAT art), Domina, A Wife and a Mother (dislike the gameplay), Defenestration (good art tho), Futanari Quest, Sisterly Lust, Femlife (A bowl of MEH!), LonaRPG, Cursed Armor, Cursed Armor 2 (a little too slow and bad RPGM combat), Haramase Simulator (Antisemitic content is a boner killer bruv), Fleshcult, Corruption of Champions 1, Something Unlimited, Earn your Freedom, XChange Life, Playhome, Nai's Training Diary, The Fall of Juliet (Great Art), Last Sovereign (Very off putting writing), Lab Rats 1, Naughty Tales of Rabbits: A Cuckold RPG, Claire's Quest (Not my kind of gameplay), Melty's Quest, Magical Girl Celesphonia, Masters of Raana
So FUCKING popular, I'll have to see the hype in time:
WMV, Being a DIK, Treasure of Nadia (hopefully better than LE), Tower of Trample (I dont dig this dude's games), D.m.D., Taffy Tales, Wild Life, UFO (I hear about it alot), Projekt Melody: Nut in Between Worlds, Eternum
Removed Bad Dev/Bad Section to decrease internet negativity, cull length.
If I missed any or you have anything to add, speak your piece in the comments.
8-7-25: Stuff moved around, 4 new GOATs added... Negativity removed. Too much of that shit going around...
Til next time…